Lawsuit Says State Double-Dipping From Dead smokers

Friday, February 23, 2001 By Martin Finucane

BOSTON – Massachusetts is unfairly taking the property of dead smokers
to pay for medical care even though the state has been reimbursed as part of a
multibillion-dollar tobacco settlement, a lawsuit contends.

The lawsuit was filed Wednesday in U.S. District Court on behalf of the
estate of Mary Watkins, who smoked cigarettes for 25 years before she died three
years ago from smoking-related illness.

Attorney Louis Massery said the lawsuit appeared to be a first and challenges
a system in place in states nationwide. He is asking a judge to give it
class-action status.

The administrators of Watkins’ estate paid the state $16,000 for her care
after selling her home last year. The lawsuit contends the Division of Medical
Assistance double-charged by taking money from Medicaid recipients’ estates
despite having received a $7.6 billion share of the $206 billion agreement over
health care costs signed in 1998 by leading cigarette makers and the attorneys
general from 46 states.

"It seems unfortunate that these low-income folks, who have nothing to
bequeath to their children except their homes are being asked to reimburse the
state," Massery said.

The lawsuit asks for an end to the seizure policy and the return of money
collected from those who suffered tobacco-related illnesses going back to the
early 1990s.

Rich McGreal, a spokesman for the Division of Medical Assistance, defended
the program.

"We’re obliged to do this under both state and federal law," he said. "By
recouping this money, we’re basically putting the money back into the system"
where it can be used to help other people.

He said the state doesn’t necessarily force the sale of the house.
Arrangements can be made, for example, to pay off the state through a home
equity loan, he said. In special circumstances, such as a disabled child living
in the home, the state waives the recovery of the money.

A spokesman for the attorney general didn’t immediately have a comment
Thursday. A spokesman for Gov. Paul Cellucci had no comment.

The medical assistance agency collects about $20 million a year through its
Estate Recovery Program, the lawsuit said. Massery said about $3 million comes
from the estates of people who died from smoking-related illnesses.

Under a 1993 law designed to shore up Medicaid’s finances, states were
required to seek reimbursements for payments made by Medicaid.

However, Massery argues that once tobacco companies began reimbursing states
for the cost of treating smoking-related illnesses, it became illegal for states
to continue collecting from the estates of people who died from smoking.

A spokeswoman for the Health Care Financing Administration in Washington,
which oversees Medicaid, said the agency had no comment on whether the Estate
Recovery Program should be changed to exempt people who died from
smoking-related illnesses.

Herb Semmel, an attorney with the National Senior Citizens Law Center, said
his organization has concerns about the entire program.

"The cause of the illness is irrelevant. They shouldn’t come after the family
homes," he said.

"Whatever little bit people have, they want to leave to their family."

Geef een reactie

Het e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Vereiste velden zijn gemarkeerd met *

Download poster


  • "Es ist schwieriger, eine vorgefaßte Meinung zu zertrümmern als ein Atom."
    (Het is moeilijker een vooroordeel aan flarden te schieten dan een atoom.)
    Albert Einstein

  • "Als je alles zou laten dat slecht is voor je gezondheid, dan ging je kapot"
    Anonieme arts

  • "The effects of other people smoking in my presence is so small it doesn't worry me."
    Sir Richard Doll, 2001

  • "Een leugen wordt de waarheid als hij maar vaak genoeg wordt herhaald"
    Joseph Goebbels, Minister van Propaganda, Nazi Duitsland

  • "First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win."
    Mahatma Gandhi

  • "There''s no such thing as perfect air. If there was, God wouldn''t have put bristles in our noses"
    Coun. Bill Clement

  • "Better a smoking freedom than a non-smoking tyranny"
    Antonio Martino, Italiaanse Minister van Defensie

  • "If smoking cigars is not permitted in heaven, I won't go."
    Mark Twain

  • I've alllllllways said that asking smokers "do you want to quit?" and reporting the results of that question, as is, is horribly misleading. It's a TWO part question. After asking if one wants to quit it must be followed up with "Why?" Ask why and the majority of the answers will be "because I'm supposed to" (victims of guilt and propaganda), not "because I want to."
    Audrey Silk, NYCCLASH